Key Points:

  • The DSM-5 does not use the term “dual diagnosis” explicitly but provides a framework for diagnosing co-occurring mental health and substance use disorders.
  • Accurate diagnosis using the DSM-5 criteria is essential for creating effective, integrated treatment plans.
  • Recognizing how substance use can mimic or mask mental illness is a critical part of the diagnostic process.

If you or a loved one is dealing with both a mental health issue and a substance use disorder, you might be searching for answers that feel rooted in clarity—not confusion. You’ve probably come across the term dual diagnosis and wondered how it fits into official psychiatric classifications like the DSM-5 (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition).

This article is designed to help bridge that gap. We’ll walk through what the DSM-5 says about co-occurring disorders, how professionals use it to make diagnoses, and what it means for treatment and recovery. You’ll find not only technical insights but also supportive guidance to help you or someone you love move toward informed action.

What Is Dual Diagnosis?

Dual diagnosis refers to the co-occurrence of a mental health disorder and a substance use disorder (SUD) in the same individual. The two conditions interact in complex ways, often intensifying each other’s symptoms and making recovery more challenging when not treated together.

While the DSM-5 doesn’t use the term “dual diagnosis” directly, it provides a comprehensive structure for identifying and classifying these co-occurring conditions. Clinicians rely on DSM-5 criteria to create accurate, individualized diagnoses that form the basis of treatment.

Common dual diagnosis examples include:

  • Major depression and alcohol use disorder
  • Anxiety disorder and benzodiazepine misuse
  • PTSD and opioid dependence
  • Bipolar disorder and stimulant addiction

Understanding how the dual diagnosis DSM-5 framework applies in these situations is crucial to getting the right care.

dual diagnosis dsm 5

How the DSM-5 Defines Co-Occurring Disorders

The DSM-5 is the gold standard for diagnosing mental and substance-related disorders. While it doesn’t explicitly label cases as “dual diagnosis,” it recognizes the frequent coexistence of mental health conditions with substance use disorders.

Separate Diagnoses, One Person

The DSM-5 allows for both a mental health diagnosis and a substance use diagnosis to be made for the same individual. For example, a person can be diagnosed with both:

Each condition is diagnosed based on its own set of criteria. Importantly, a person must meet the full diagnostic threshold for both disorders. The presence of one doesn’t automatically confirm the other.

Substance-Induced vs. Independent Disorders

A critical component of the dual diagnosis DSM-5 process is determining whether the mental health symptoms are substance-induced or independent of substance use.

Substance-Induced Disorders

Symptoms appear during or shortly after substance use and often resolve after detox. These include:

  • Alcohol-induced depression
  • Cocaine-induced psychosis

Independent Mental Disorders 

Symptoms occur regardless of substance use or persist long after use has ended.

Clinicians may ask questions like:

  • Did the symptoms begin before the substance use?
  • Do symptoms persist during abstinence?
  • Is there a history of mental health issues without drug/alcohol involvement?

Answering these questions is essential for developing an appropriate treatment plan.

dual diagnosis dsm 5

Diagnosing Dual Diagnosis with DSM-5: What Professionals Look For

The process of assessing and diagnosing dual diagnosis under DSM-5 guidelines is detailed and requires a nuanced approach. Mental health professionals must conduct a thorough evaluation to rule out mimicking symptoms and consider all potential influences.

Here’s what that process typically involves:

1. Detailed Clinical Interviews

Clinicians gather a full psychiatric and substance use history, including:

  • Age of onset for symptoms
  • Duration and frequency of substance use
  • Periods of sobriety and related symptom changes
  • Family history of mental illness or addiction

This timeline helps clarify which disorder emerged first and how they interact.

2. Screening and Assessment Tools

Several validated tools help assess dual diagnosis under DSM-5 standards:

  • SCID-5 (Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-5)
  • AUDIT (Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test)
  • DAST (Drug Abuse Screening Test)
  • PHQ-9 (for depression)
  • GAD-7 (for anxiety)

Using these tools ensures that the diagnosis is not just based on self-report but on standardized measures.

3. Medical and Psychiatric Evaluation

Sometimes, physical health conditions or medications can mimic psychiatric symptoms. A complete evaluation may include:

  • Blood tests or urine screenings
  • Neurological assessments
  • Review of prescribed medications

Ruling out medical causes is part of responsible, ethical diagnosis.

DSM-5 Diagnostic Criteria: Examples of Co-Occurring Diagnoses

To give you a clearer understanding of how dual diagnosis is evaluated through the DSM-5, let’s explore a couple of common diagnostic combinations that illustrate how co-occurring mental health and substance use disorders are assessed.

Example 1: Major Depressive Disorder and Alcohol Use Disorder

Major Depressive Disorder, as outlined in the DSM-5, includes symptoms such as a depressed mood that persists for most of the day, a noticeable loss of interest or pleasure in almost all activities, significant fatigue or loss of energy, and persistent feelings of worthlessness or guilt. These symptoms must interfere with daily functioning and occur nearly every day over a sustained period.

In combination, a person may also meet the diagnostic criteria for Alcohol Use Disorder. This includes drinking more or for longer periods than originally intended, experiencing repeated unsuccessful attempts to cut back or stop drinking, developing strong cravings or urges to consume alcohol, and continuing to drink despite it causing social, physical, or professional problems.

If a person meets the full criteria for both disorders independently—and if these symptoms persist across different areas of life such as at work, home, or in relationships—a clinician may diagnose both conditions as part of a dual diagnosis case.

Example 2: Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder and Opioid Use Disorder

In another common combination, an individual may struggle with both PTSD and Opioid Use Disorder. PTSD, according to DSM-5 standards, is marked by recurrent and distressing flashbacks or intrusive memories, intentional avoidance of trauma-related cues or situations, and heightened states of alertness such as hypervigilance or an exaggerated startle response.

At the same time, the person may exhibit signs of opioid dependence. This includes taking opioids in larger amounts or over a longer period than originally planned, experiencing tolerance or withdrawal symptoms, neglecting responsibilities due to drug use, and having a persistent desire or repeated failed efforts to stop using the substance.

In these cases, the clinician must determine whether opioid use began as a way to self-medicate and cope with trauma, or whether PTSD symptoms are actually part of the cycle of intoxication and withdrawal. This careful differentiation is vital for making accurate diagnoses and developing a treatment plan that addresses both conditions holistically.

Why Accurate Diagnosis Matters in Treatment

Misdiagnosing or failing to recognize a dual diagnosis can lead to ineffective treatment. For example, if only the substance use disorder is treated while the underlying trauma is ignored, relapse is likely. Similarly, if only the mental health symptoms are addressed without targeting substance use, treatment may fail to make meaningful progress.

Accurate DSM-5 diagnosis supports:

  • Integrated treatment plans
  • Tailored therapy approaches (e.g., trauma-informed care, CBT for SUD)
  • Medication management that considers interactions between psychiatric meds and substance use

When both disorders are identified early and treated together, individuals have a significantly higher chance of achieving long-term recovery.

What to Do If You Suspect a Dual Diagnosis

Suspecting a dual diagnosis in yourself or someone close can be overwhelming. You may feel uncertain about what to prioritize, or scared of what treatment might look like. The most important thing is to not delay seeking help.

1. Reach Out to a Dual Diagnosis Professional

Find a provider or treatment center that specializes in co-occurring disorders. General psychiatric or addiction-only care may miss key parts of the picture.

2. Be Honest in Evaluations

When answering intake questions or speaking to a clinician, be open about all symptoms—mental, emotional, and behavioral.

3. Ask About DSM-5-Based Diagnosis

Inquire whether the professional is using DSM-5 standards in your evaluation. This ensures your diagnosis is based on widely accepted clinical criteria.

4. Don’t Be Discouraged by Complexity

Yes, dual diagnosis can be complicated. But the good news is that with accurate diagnosis and integrated care, recovery is not only possible—it’s sustainable.

Take the First Step Toward Clarity and Healing

Understanding the dual diagnosis DSM-5 framework is the first step toward meaningful recovery. If you're looking for care that considers the full complexity of your experience—not just your symptoms—New Horizons Recovery Centers offers dual diagnosis treatment in Ohio and Pennsylvania tailored to individuals navigating both substance use and mental health challenges.

Our approach is rooted in thorough assessment, compassionate care, and integrated treatment planning. We know that co-occurring disorders don't happen in isolation, and neither should your recovery. With licensed professionals who apply DSM-5 diagnostic criteria, we provide the clarity and support needed to move forward—step by step.

Let today be the day you stop trying to figure it all out alone. Reach out now and start your path toward balanced healing—mentally, emotionally, and physically.